Tuesday, September 22, 2009

Our View - 'Death panel' bunk drowns out other parts of health care discussion

Printed in the Iowa City Press-Citizen, Aug. 15, 2009.

We understand how the pressure is on Iowa Sen. Chuck Grassley to appease his Republican base. And we can excuse those occasional misstatements that happen when the national media pay close attention to your every word. But we're at a loss over how Iowa's senior senator -- and the ranking member of the Senate Finance Committee -- stoked irrational fears this week about a provision for "advance care planning consultation" in the House version of the health care overhaul bill.

"There is some fear because in the House bill, there is counseling for end of life. And from that standpoint, you have every right to fear," Grassley said during an outdoor meeting Wednesday. "You shouldn't have counseling at the end of life. You ought to have counseling 20 years before you're going to die. You ought to plan these things out."

One could assume Grassley was just being overly empathetic. Maybe he was just telling the crowd that he understood their fears about all the misinformation and negative hoopla surrounding a provision in the House bill that would pay for patients to be able to sit down with a doctor and talk about what they want for their end-of-life care. Maybe Grassley was trying to dispel the rumors -- like President Obama tried to do earlier in the week in New Hampshire -- and he just got carried away with his "aw shucks" rhetoric.

But then Grassley said, "And I don't have any problem with things like living wills. But they ought to be done within the family. We should not have a government program that determines if you're going to pull the plug on Grandma."

What Grassley says is true: No one wants want a government program to determine when people should die. But Grassley also knows that there is no such provision in the House bill. And he also knows that reform opponents have taken the provision for voluntary "advance care planning consultation" and transmogrified it into having a panel of bloodless government bureaucrats decide who lives and who dies.

If he was trying to alleviate his audience's fears, he failed miserably. Instead, he stoked those fears to become even hotter.

Discussing end-of-life care

Talking about end-of-life care is a subject that most people already find scary enough. We fear that the media firestorm around this non-existent "death panels" not only will distract people from a rational discussion of long-need health care reform, but will also scare people further away from taking the steps necessary to make sure their family and their doctor know their preferences for end-of-life care.

If people don't prepare some form of advanced care directive, then their family members are left trying to figure out what their wishes would have been. If those family members disagree passionately enough, then the courts are left to decide.

Indeed, if the media circus surrounding the Terri Schiavo case in 2005 had any positive consequences, it was to get family members talking with each other about what type of medical intervention they would consider essential -- a feeding tube, a breathing apparatus, etc. -- and at what point they would just like to let go.

Such discussions are not merely theoretical. The only thing each of us knows for certain is that we are going to die one day. If that death comes quickly, no decision needs to be made. If it is prolonged, however, then the situation can become overwhelmingly complicated.

Avoiding a family, legal meltdown

Iowa law sets up a process that allows for the withholding or withdrawing of life-sustaining procedures if a doctor agrees with the person who has been appointed to make decision for the individual. If there is no one appointed, the law basically sets up a hierarchy of individuals who can consult and agree with a physician: The appointed proxy, the incapacitated person's guardian, the person's spouse, a majority of the person's adult children, the person's parents and then the person's adult siblings.

If discussions about end-of-life care can be done when everyone is lucid and able to think rationally -- albeit the discussions themselves can often get emotional -- then they save everyone pain and anguish at a time when few are able to think rationally.

Government has an interest in encouraging such decisions to be made ahead of time. And the House bill simply provides for people who voluntarily want to have such a discussion with a qualified physician or nurse practitioner.

Grassley is right in that the most important part of this process is for family members to talk with each other about these decisions. Because people change their minds about what counts as appropriate life-saving measures -- a healthy 35-year-old will view these issues differently when she becomes a chronically ill 75-year-old -- it's important that these discussions happen on a regular basis.

Hopefully those discussions will continue despite Grassley's ill-chosen words.

Our View - Women's historian herself becomes part of history

Printed in the Iowa City Press-Citizen, Aug. 13, 2009.

Since 1971, Linda Kerber has been teaching history at the University of Iowa. Throughout that time, she has been working to overturn the once conventional assumption that the historical events that matter most -- the ones that require the most serious historical scholarship -- involve men alone.

Digging into historical sources overlooked in the past by historians who thought them unimportant, Kerber has been able to reconstruct the lives and experiences of previously unsung women and to present those stories in such books as "No Constitutional Right to Be Ladies: Women and the Obligations of Citizenship" (1999).

Now the historian who has made a career out of documenting the lives of other women has been recognized herself as a woman whose story needs to be documented and shared with all Iowans. The Iowa Commission on the Status of Women is inducting Kerber into its Iowa Women's Hall of Fame (for a full list of names, visit www.friendsoficsw.org/4.html).

Kerber said she is accepting the recognition on behalf of the generation of feminist historians who, like her, came to professional maturity in the late 1960s or early 1970s. When Kerber's cohort started looking around for what to write about after finishing their dissertations, they found a growing women's movement hungry for the history they could provide.

"I've only recently come to realize now how incredibly lucky we were," Kerber said. "We found ourselves at a moment in which there was a need for a history that had not been written and that both men and women needed to write."

Kerber said she also has depended immeasurably on the smattering of female historians who came before her generation. Since receiving news of the recognition, Kerber said her thoughts have turned to the late Louise Noun -- a fellow Iowa Women's Hall of Fame member who conceptualized, initiated and endowed the Iowa Women's Archives in 1991 so that future historians would have access to the records.

"(Noun) had to do what she did largely alone," Kerber said. "That's why she became so committed to developing the archive."

Having been at UI for nearly four decades, Kerber still finds herself adjusting to the fact that she is no longer one of the "young ones who didn't follow the rules." She has served as president of the American Historical Association, the Organization of American Historians and the American Studies Association. And her mentoring has inspired at least two more generations of scholars.

"I've been witness to her powerful impact on students at the University of Iowa and elsewhere," said Mary Bennett, who is special collections coordinator for the State Historical Society of Iowa and who studied with Kerber in the 1970s. "She opened the door for many young females in the profession."

In her letter of support for Kerber's nomination, University of Arizona professor Judy Nolte Temple added, "Kerber's national and international reputation brings honor to the state of Iowa, her adopted home. Linda has held many national presidencies and been a visiting scholar in a variety of places, but she returns to Iowa, where she has diligently trained the next generation of scholars who create new knowledge about women."

We agree with Nolte Temple, and we're glad the Iowa Commission on the Status of Women is recognizing this inspiring historian herself for being an important part of Iowa history.

Our View - When should a city shut down a bar like Los Cocos?

Printed in the Iowa City Press-Citizen, Aug. 12, 2009.

Although bar owner Heather German decided Tuesday to close Los Cocos permanently, Iowa City officials are left with an important lingering question: Under what conditions and under what authority could and should city government close an establishment for presenting a sustained, serious risk to public safety?

It's a question that the city attorney's office will need to explore before Iowa City ever again sees a bar that in its first 11 months, according to police, requests more than 210 calls for service -- which required 396 officers to be dispatched and resulted in 74 arrests and three warrant arrests. A bar that then, in its 12th month, has patrons allegedly involved in a stabbing, a display of a handgun and eventually a shooting.

The Iowa City Council does have the authority to deny a liquor license renewal request, but even that's not enough to shut down a bar quickly. The downtown bars Etc and the Field House, whose license renewals the council denied last month, have the option to appeal the decision to the state and stay open while their appeals are heard.

But the Etc and Field House decisions were based on the number of times police had issued citations to patrons for underage possession of alcohol. Police say Los Cocos doesn't have an excessive number of alcohol violations or underage possession charges -- just a disproportionately high need for police response.

After contacting German and holding what Police Chief Sam Hargadine called a "frank discussion," the police, the city and German were able to reach an agreement about what problems the bar would have to address to keep its license.

The council agreed with the police recommendation last month and gave Los Cocos a six-month renewal with stipulations that the bar owners and staff:

• Not violate any laws.

• Enforce occupancy limits.

• Sufficiently staff the bar with appropriately trained people.

• Meet monthly with the police to discuss concerns.

• Not host any after-hours events.

• Eject patrons causing problems, ban them for the calendar year and turn over their names to the police.

• Continue to report all criminal activity even as they work to achieve an immediate reduction of fight, disturbance, assault, weapons, intoxication, littering and narcotics calls.

But last month's stabbing and Sunday's shooting suggests an escalation of violence rather than "an immediate reduction."

German, who said she was in Los Cocos every night the bar was open except Wednesdays, said she always felt safe in the bar until early Sunday morning. That's when, after word spread that someone in the bar might have a gun, employees cut the music and — without explaining why — asked everyone to leave the bar and re-enter after being passed over with a metal-detecting wand by staff.

Police have not said German or her staff did anything wrong in how they reacted to the situation. Nevertheless, police also say that, while standing outside waiting to re-enter Los Cocos, Bernard James Butler of Cedar Rapids shot Cortez Parker of Iowa City in the abdomen during a fight.

Even German agreed that whatever steps the bar took to address the violence were inadequate. She said she wanted to close the bar for a while to see if the problems in the neighborhood will die down, but told the Press-Citizen Tuesday night that she had decided to close the bar for good.

City officials didn't seem to be in a rush to close the bar. Iowa City mayor Regenia Bailey said she did not expect the city council to address Los Cocos' liquor license until it came up for renewal at the end of the year. And Iowa City Police Sgt. Mike Brotherton said that, while Los Cocos has its problems, "they're not any more significant than other bars in the downtown."

Given recent events, we're glad German has taken the step on her own to close her bar. But we'd still like to know the answer to the lingering question: Under what conditions and under what authority could and should city government close an establishment — anywhere in the city — for presenting a sustained, serious risk to public safety?

Our View - Questions for Iowa City School Board candidates

Printed in the Iowa City Press-Citizen, Aug. 8, 2009.

Here are some of the issues we're going to ask the eight Iowa City School Board candidates before the Sept. 8 election. We suggest you ask the candidates about them as well.

Decommissioning Roosevelt

• What, if anything, should the board have done differently when considering whether to decommission Roosevelt Elementary as a K-6 school and to build a new elementary school near Camp Cardinal Road?

• What does the district need to do for the next two years to ensure a safe and productive learning environment in a school building they no longer consider a good investment for continuing as a K-6 school?

• What should be done with the Roosevelt building after the new school opens in 2011?

Redrawing boundaries

The decision to close Roosevelt and to build a new Camp Cardinal school will require redrawing boundaries between the west-side schools of Roosevelt, Kirkwood, Horn and Weber. But there also seems to be a groundswell of support for addressing the gross disparities between the district's elementary schools by redrawing boundaries districtwide.

• How do you think the board should go about redrawing school boundaries? What kind of public input should be allowed? What kind of timeframe would be required?

• As the board redraws the boundaries, which factors should be considered more important: geographic proximity, minimizing disruptions in students' educational experience, using current capacity, school size, equalizing educational opportunities or balancing socio-economic demographics?

• Should school attendance areas be considered primarily static entities that the board seldom changes, or is it time to start thinking about school boundaries as being more fluid and requiring more regular evaluation?

Neighborhood schools

The district's five-year facility improvement plan released earlier this year didn't include any major improvements for the district's two oldest elementaries, Mann and Longfellow. Because of the board's decision to decomission Roosevelt in 2011, groups like We Love Our Neighborhood Schools worry that this is a policy of "benign neglect" toward those older schools.

• How do you define a "neighborhood school"? Which schools in the district do think fit your definition? What is the value of maintaining (or implementing) a "neighborhood school" philosophy?

• How committed should the district be to keep existing facilities functioning as long as possible? At what point is it in the district's best interest to tear down an existing facility and to rebuild it somewhere else?

• Would the Iowa City Council have been out of line if they had sent a letter to the school board expressing their concerns about how closing Roosevelt would negatively affect the Miller-Orchard neighborhood?

Educational quality and content

In philosophy and in practice, the district has focused on making its educational facilities as comparable as possible. While there are distinct differences between the schools -- such as, mobility rates, poverty rates, PTO contributions and standardized test results -- the district tries to provide the similar educational quality and content at each school.

• How much of a priority should it be for the district to ensure educational quality and contents are as similar as possible for each school?

• As the district considers redrawing elementary boundaries and bringing a third high school online, is it time for the district to allow (or even to encourage) some of its schools to become magnet schools with more specialized or individualized curriculum?

Finances

• The district has been in slashing mode in order to eliminate about $6 million from its budget over the next two years. How fair and effective do you think the district has been in deciding what to cut? How might the district have avoided the short fall in the first place?

• How well is the school board living up to the promises made before the 2007 SILO vote?

New high school

During public discussions of high school enrollment, the overwhelming sentiment seemed to be: It's not a question of if the district will build a new comprehensive high school; it's a question of when. But the district recently estimated that a new comprehensive high school with a capacity for 800 students annually would cost at least $1.7 million to operate.

• The High School Enrollment Task Force recently recommended the board should move toward building a new comprehensive high school as soon as the district has "adequate student enrollment" and "it is financially feasible." What do those vague phrases mean to you?

• How should the district address overcrowding at West and underutilization at City before a new high school comes online?

'Those people from Chicago'

As soon as any child enrolls in the district, he or she becomes a student of the district. As such, any problems facing the Iowa City School District shouldn't be framed as us-against-them, or as "the outside students are threatening our good Iowa City kids."

• To what degree is the district responsible for the academic success of every student?

• How well are administrators, staff, teachers and families working together to ensure that students know what to expect and how to behave?

Board/community relations

Past school boards have wrestled with the question of how to get more community participation in their sparsely attended meetings. This year, however, the meetings have been filled with parents, teachers and other area residents concerned about how the board's decisions will affect their school and community.

• How well has the board listened to the concerns of the public? How could its listening skills be improved?

• Should the board always address the public through a consensus opinion, or would it be better for individual members to be allowed speak out publicly on school issues as individuals?

Our View - The benefits of Iowa City bars going 21-only

Printed in the Iowa City Press-Citizen, Aug. 5, 2009.

Boy, we caught a little glimmer of hope during the July 28 Iowa City Council meeting.

George Etre, owner of Etc., told the council that he was thinking about making his bar 21-only because Iowa City is now including the rate of Possession of Alcohol Under the Legal Age charges as one of the criteria for evaluating liquor license renewal requests. Since February, if a bar has an average of more than 1.0 PAULAs per police visit, then the police department automatically recommends the council deny the license renewal request.

The council, of course, still has the option to ignore the police department's recommendation -- and, say, recommend a six-month probationary license with stipulations. But bar owners probably shouldn't take the probationary license unless they are confident they can get their establishments into compliance with the law in those next six months. Otherwise, the owners actually hurt their chances with the state -- or the courts -- if they choose to appeal a council's eventual denial.

That's why Etre told the council he was interested in the possibility of going 21-only.

"I don't feel comfortable telling you to extend my liquor license for six months or a year or however long, knowing that I have to get PAULAs under 1.0 because there's so many variables involved in the PAULA that are out of my hands, that I can't control," Etre said during the July 28 meeting. "For me it would be easier to just be a 21-bar, not deal with 19- and 20-year-olds, not have to worry about PAULAs."

Denying a license renewal because of PAULA rates, after all, is very different than denying a license renewal because of the number of alcohol sales to minors. The one is a sin of commission in which a bar employee is clearly violating the law. The other is a sin of omission in which bars may have done nothing wrong -- other than to provide a locale in which underage people can enter and get their older friends to buy alcohol for them.

By holding bar owners accountable for the underage drinkers in their establishment, the city may have altered the local economic environment just enough that more bar owners -- like Etre -- will be looking to negotiate with the council to go 21-only voluntarily.

Those negotiations, however, need to take place before a bar is out of compliance. That's why we think the council was right to vote 6-1 to deny Etre's renewal request -- despite a modicum of improvement between February and June -- and to vote unanimously to deny the request from the Fieldhouse bar.

The council's decision isn't the last step in the process, however; it's just the beginning. Bar owners have every right to appeal the decision to the state's Alcoholic Beverages Division, and if they don't like the answer there, to appeal the decision through the courts. It could take years to reach a final conclusion -- years in which the bar gets to keep its license and keep operating.

Yet appealing the decision has economic consequences in that it dramatically increases a bar's cost of doing business. Bars could see their dram shop insurance rate go through the roof, or they could lose their insurance altogether -- and thus have to go out of business. Plus, bar owners will have to pay what's sure to be hefty fees to get lawyers to argue their case before the city council, the state board and the courts.

Of the 110 liquor licenses in Iowa City, police say that only six are in jeopardy of having a rate of more than 1.0 PAULAs per police visit for the past 12 months. Although many of those 110 licenses belong to restaurants, the vast majority of bars in Iowa City are still able to comply with this very reasonable standard.

We highly encourage bars that are unable to comply to think about the benefits of going 21-only.

Our View - Once shooting probe is completed, officials must release all details

Printed Iowa City Press-Citizen, Aug. 1, 2009.

HOMICIDE, n. The slaying of one human being by another. There are four kinds of homicide: felonious, excusable, justifiable, and praiseworthy, but it makes no great difference to the person slain whether he fell by one kind or another -- the classification is for advantage of the lawyers." -- Ambrose Bierce, "The Devil's Dictionary" (1911).

There nothing good about the shooting of a homeless Sudanese refugee by a 24-year veteran of the Johnson County Sheriff's Department. And while the Iowa City police and state agencies investigate the shooting, the local community is left to debate which of the four labels listed above should be attached to the death.

Initial police reports say that on July 24, 26-year-old John Deng got into an argument with 63-year-old John Bohnenkamp -- an argument that turned physical and resulted in Bohnenkamp being stabbed. Deputy Terry Stotler then lethally shot Deng after the man made what the plain-clothed officer perceived as a threatening move toward Bohnenkamp.

The situation is further complicated politically because Deng -- who has a list of encounters with Iowa City police stretching back two years -- had no known address for at least five months. A newly formed community group, Iowa Citizens for Social Change, already has been pressing the police to release more information about the shooting.

Because this is a community where many can recall vividly a police shooting 13 years ago, we too hope the reports from the police and state investigators will answer all of the community's questions. We urge investigators, after they have completed their investigations and announced their conclusions, to make public as much information as possible.

In the meantime, here are the answers to some of the questions the community has been asking over the past week.

Questions authorities have answered:

• Stotler is a civil deputy. What exactly does a civil deputy do? Why are they in plain clothes? And how much training do they have to carry a gun?

Civil deputies are responsible for serving court summons, documents and eviction notices. They have as much training as any other deputies, but they normally perform their duties in plain clothes, carrying only a badge, a gun and handcuffs. A uniformed officer, in contrast, typically would have access to pepper spray, a Taser or a night stick.

• Who will make the final determination of whether Stotler's shooting of Deng was justifiable?

Once local authorities have completed their investigation -- with the inclusion of an autopsy and toxicology report -- the updated materials will be sent to the state attorney general's office. Officials in that office will determine whether Stotler could have reasonably perceived that he or another person was under the threat of deadly force. They will make the decision on whether to file criminal charges against Stotler.

• What information from the investigation will be made public?

If charges are filed against Stotler, then information from the investigation could be made public through testimony and court evidence. If no charges are filed, we hope the state still provides more than enough information to justify the decision.

Questions still being investigated:

• Had Deng been drinking or using drugs?

The toxicology reports won't be back for weeks.

• How much (if any) had Bohnenkamp been drinking before he confronted Deng for breaking bottles on the 300 block of Prentiss Street?

We don't know.

• What was said to escalate the confrontation so quickly?

Bohnenkamp has offered no comment on the incident.

• Did Stotler identify himself as a police officer when he drew his gun?

According to police, several witnesses say that he did.

• Did Deng have a knife in his hand when Stotler shot him? And was he acting in a threatening manner?

According to police, several witnesses say that he did have a knife and was being threatening. Two men told another media outlet that Deng was not being threatening. The police have recovered the knife, but they said they are not releasing a description of the knife because the matter is still under investigation.

Questions that require more police, media and public research:

• If Deng is one of the "lost boys of the Sudan," how did he end up in Iowa City? Why did he stay? Why didn't his family know that he was homeless?

This could be an interesting story. There are many books and films about the more than 27,000 boys who were displaced and orphaned during the Second Sudanese Civil War. Through help from the public, the police recently notified Deng's family members who came to Iowa City to identify the body.

However Deng came to Iowa City, he has had several run-ins with the Iowa City police in the past two years. Police records show he was arrested for public intoxication on July 11 by Iowa City police, his third such offense since March 2008. Deng was arrested for drunken driving in August 2007 by Iowa City police and has several other offenses on his record, including a charge of disorderly conduct -- fighting or violent behavior stemming from a June 2007 incident.

• How well did Deng speak and understand English?

Iowa City Police Sgt. Troy Kelsay said, despite being born in another country, Deng seemed to have an understanding of the English language in his past experiences with the Iowa City police. Crissy Canganelli, the director of Shelter House, said the shelter staff ranked Deng as a 5 out of 10 in terms of language ability, with 10 being fluent.

Our View - We need to make sure the watchers are watching the watchers

Originally printed in the Iowa City Press-Citizen, July 31, 2009.

The recent news stories about the early morning Feb. 11 drunken-driving arrest of state Rep. Kerry Burt (D-Waterloo) have brought to light some disturbing questions about how well Iowa's lawmakers can oversee their own rules on ethics and campaign disclosures when the Legislature is in session.

A report filed Wednesday shows lobbyists for the Iowa Pharmacy Association paid about $2,400 in drinks for the Feb. 10 reception that Burt attended a few hours before his arrest. Unfortunately, the association didn't file the report until after reporters recently started asking questions about the Feb. 10 reception in the Embassy Suites hotel in downtown Des Moines -- a reception attended by lawmakers and Gov. Chet Culver.

That's five months late. Iowa law requires that such session function reports be filed within five business days following the date of the reception if it takes place during the Legislature's session and every lawmaker is invited. And it seems unlikely that anyone any time soon would have noticed the report hadn't been filed without the recent interest in Burt's arrest and the additional allegations that Burt failed to make proper tuition payments to a state-run school his children attended.

The pharmacy association CEO Thomas Temple told The Des Moines Register that the late filing was due to administrative oversight.

"We made the House and Senate offices aware of the reception, so it's not like we were trying to hide anything," he said.

But even taking the lobbyists at their word, the situation shows the state House and Senate ethics committees aren't being diligent enough in double-checking the reports. Back in 2005, state lawmakers stripped enforcement authority for session function reports from the nonpartisan Iowa Ethics and Campaign Disclosure Board and gave it to the ethics committees themselves. One advocacy group, Iowa Citizens for Community Improvement, said Thursday that allowing the lawmakers to oversee themselves has resulted directly in fewer reports being filed.

"What other profession in the state is allowed to regulate themselves?" said Ed Rethman, a group member from West Des Moines, in a news release. "Are doctors allowed to license themselves?"

Burt's alleged behavior during his Feb. 11 arrest highlights the many problems with allowing lawmakers to police themselves. According to police reports, an Ankeny police officer parked at a gas station noticed Burt's car had a flat tire and front-end damage. A preliminary breath test showed Burt had a blood-alcohol content of .131 -- well over the .08 percent legal limit for driving. Burt -- a Waterloo fireman -- then allegedly asked for a professional courtesy from the officers. The report states that Burt also began to name drop that he was a state legislator who had been at a reception and restaurant with the governor and thus couldn't be arrested. Eventually, he was charged with first-offense operating while intoxicated.

We think the allegations against Burt are beyond the pale for an elected official. But we're equally concerned that state law doesn't give the Iowa Ethics and Campaign Disclosure Board enforcement jurisdiction over the filing of these reports from the lobbyists who are paying to wine and dine such officials.